How many idiots does it take to fill out a 1040?

“Oh crud, we need to do our taxes,” I recently told my husband as I do every year around this time.

After exhausting every reason to procrastinate ÔÇô cleaning out the vegetable drawer, perusing old Hickory Farms catalogues left over from Christmas, clipping toenails, surfing E-bay for vintage bar signs, napping ÔÇô we finally had to face the music.

Coffee and a folder haphazardly filled with paperwork in hand, my husband and I reluctantly plopped down in front of our computer to complete the dreaded annual tax forms.

We haven’t had the best luck preparing our tax forms over the years, and are conditioned to avoid the experience. Despite my law degree and my husband’s master’s degree in financial management, neither of us ever grasped the simple concepts relevant to our personal income tax forms.

In law school, I took a Tax Law courseand could write a scholarly paper on whether the federal income tax is a direct tax or an excise tax based on the Sixteenth Amendment and the Supreme Court’s opinion in the Pollock case, but I struggled with my 1040EZ.

My husband’s master’s thesis was entitled “Congress, Defense, and the Deficit: An Analysis of the FY 1996 Budget Process in the 1O4th Congress,” but he couldn’t tell the difference between short and long term capital gains if his retirement depended on it.

But every year, we begrudgingly spread out our paperwork and somehow fulfill our obligations as taxpayers.

One year, we wanted to act like grown ups, so we hired an accountant while living in Virginia Beach. He was a charming southern gentleman with blue eyes, silver white hair and a matching tidy moustache. He called me “ma’am” and politely sat with us one balmy evening in the early days of spring. Over the season’s first lemonades, we casually chatted about our finances, and he gathered all the information he needed to prepare and file our returns. It was so easy, we wondered why we hadn’t been doing it this way all along.

The next year, we tried to contact our charming accountant to do our taxes again, but strangely, he never returned our calls.

We soon found out that he couldn’t call us back because he was locked up in the big house. Turns out, our southern gentleman was politely holding himself out as a CPA without a license, embezzling from clients, and obtaining money under false pretenses. Oops. Back to the drawing board.

Since then, we have been using Turbo Tax, a seemingly idiot-proof program which leads the user through a simplified series of questions designed to accurately calculate all income and deductions. Somehow, my husband and I still have no idea what is going on.

“Do we qualify for the child tax credit?” I asked, as my husband slurped his coffee. “Hell if I know . . . just do whatever we did last year, that seemed to work,” he said nonchalantly.

“I forget, do we have Roth IRAs or regular IRAs?” I said a few minutes later. Riffling through a pile of papers, my husband found our statements, which might as well have been written in Chinese. “Roth, but what the heck is a recharacterized contribution?”

My eyes started to cross as I tried to decipher our mutual fund papers. “Is cost basis the same as purchase price?” I said, searching my faded memory bank. “I don’t know, just punch in $200 and see what happens,” my husband suggested.

After four hours, two pots of coffee, three calls to our financial manager, and at least a dozen choice expletives, we finally got it all figured out and dutifully sent our forms off to Uncle Sam.

We won’t get our return check for several weeks, but rest assured, we’ve already spent it, and lost the receipt. When our bank statements arrive, we won’t know how to balance the checkbook. And next spring, we’ll be back in front of our computer, dazed and confused all over again. Apparently, a few more things in life are certain asidefrom death and taxes.

Posted in

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Great essay, Lisa, funny and too true.Hint: next year take your receipts to the library where AARP accountants will do your taxes for free. You don’t need to be a senior to use their services. I’ve seen many younger people who appear as confused as I.

    I wish we would have had more time together at EBWW. After our first hello, I didn’t see you again the entire weekend.

    • Thanks for the hint, Sharon. Yes, I walked around Erma in a half-panicked, half-guilty state because either I felt I needed to meet more people, or I wasn’t talking more to the people I’d already met. It was a catch 22.

  2. Hahaha this was very interesting! I personally I no yet at the crossroads of filling out tax forms, but I already am starting to dread it lol
    My parents actually go to H and R Block to do the taxes and it seems to work out for them…

  3. I’m one of those odd people that loves doing their taxes. I actually look forward to it every year. I know, I know. I’m also the kid who played with the box instead of the gift at Christmas. 😉

  4. Extremely funny and I remember I used to file taxes too. Then I started my own business and everyone told me it would make absolute sense to hire an accountant; he/she would pay for him/herself….. Not sure about that last statement, but I did enjoy my extra free time and only felt a little bad handing over my shoebox (literally) with all my papers. Those were the days…
    And now? I recently moved to Mexico, and just realized I’ll be in tax-hell again coming April 2013 (I think?). OMG, and I don’t even speak Spanish yet…
    Congrats on the freshly pressed.

  5. Well now I feel better that you both with all your degrees still find the forms mind-boggling. I think I do great but always get hung up on something. This year it was W-2s. At some point I stop thinking and just say, it’s good enough, I don’t care about searching for any more deductions, I just want it done. Maybe that’s a ploy to frustrate people so we give up our additional $5 return from deductions or something but multiply that $5 by millions of people and the government has a great racket! I’m just still stinging from doing my taxes as you can tell! After this post I refuse to talk taxes for 295 more days. Love the post despite my griping!! 🙂

    • I totally agree with your theory that the government wants to keep us all (degrees or not) confused enough to give in and stop haggling for the deductions/credits we deserve. Grrr….

  6. One of the biggest reasons I’m in no rush to become a “adult”. I never understood why something so important has to be so difficult, even filling out a fafsa is a headache in and of itself.

  7. i feel the same way. you would think that as an intelligent and educated person (masters degree, currently pursuing a phd) that i would be able to manage taxes at a basic level (my income is incredibly modest and should be “simple”). just never seems to work out that way.

    further evidence that a simpler, fairer tax code is needed…?

  8. Even so, I still think that you’re blessed; down here in Mexico we’re still depending in -at least- one accountant to decently fill out our tax forms. The SAT (mexican IRS) is making some changes to allow us to fill the tax forms by ourselves, but as you said, it’s still written in Chinese and, being positive, a nightmare.

    Good luck with your forms this year!

  9. US taxes are a nightmare. The actual amount collected as a percentage is not all that bad, in the final analysis, but the process is just insanely irritating. Much more so than UK taxes for instance. Honestly, the US has one of the most complicated tax codes, with the most frustrating forms and byzantine bureaucracy driving it. Next year will be my very last filing with the IRS (I’ve renounced citizenship) and I will be delighted not have to pay an accountant to sort it all out any more.

  10. And here I thought I was only puzzled about doing my taxes because I’m 21! What’s even more confusing than filing your taxes is having to file an amended return – doh! You actually have to print it out, stick it in an envelope, put postage on it, put it in your mail box, and hope to God you put the correct IRS mailing address on there!

    I thoroughly enjoyed your post. Thanks for the laugh! 🙂

  11. I am very happy to pay taxes and would even be willing to pay more for more services but in exchange for not having to go through this process! It has too much of a punitive quality to it. In China, for instance, they do not file income taxes because the government sees no point, given that, like the US, all the money is created by the monetary agency and they know all that goes in and out anyway. I say do not tax advances on the value of property but consider all financial instruments regular income and abolish the concept of capital gains. The coffers of the state would be loaded and people could file taxes in just a couple of pages. -“tarotworldtour”

  12. You’re a brave woman to do your own taxes! I’ve used the same accountant for the last 10 years and she seems legit enough (doesn’t meet me on street corners in a trenchcoat, hat and sunglasses).

    Hilarious post- I’m following now!

  13. A clever person once said that the only two certainties in life are death and taxes. And where there are taxes, there are 1040s – or, as it is known in my little corner of the world – RF1030.

    Until now, I have found filling in my tax forms a rather straightforward procedure. However, being a freelance writer complicates things. In 2011, for the first time, I have not only several employers, but several different types of incomes. I do not even know the relevant terms in my native Norwegian, so I won’t try figuring out what they are called in English. Alas, all these income sources still don’t pay nearly enough to hire an accountant.

    Well, I guess reading and commenting on this blog entry was my last attempt at procrastination. I’ll better get started on that RF1030 and its even more annoying relative, the RF1224. Wish me luck, I certainly need it…

    • 1994, March 11, Los Angeles Times

      “Einstein Admits He Had To Call in Income Tax Expert”, Page 1

      Los Angeles, California (Pro Quest)

      🙂

  14. This is so very very true…. I did my first tax return this year past, and I’m still in a slight daze about it all. They even have a simple downloadable program here in Aus that does a good deal of it for you, but they really need to dumb the terms down to : Money spent on work clothes, money paid in rent, la di da simple man speak! All I know is that we earnt a load of money and then spent it all >.<

  15. I had the highest grade in my Taxation & Finance class at a Top Ten university, and it stunned me, because I had no idea what was going on in that class. I actually did a little better with my tax forms — UNTIL I started using TurboTax. It leaves me unnerved every year, even more than my own unaided mistakes. (But it just seems easier than actually reading the instructions anymore.)

  16. Don’t feel bad. I recently read that the tax code is now four (I think it was four) times the length of the COMBINED works of Shakespeare. Add to this that Congress gets a “bad report” if it doesn’t enact enough laws in a given year and no wonder we spend most of our GDP on filing our tax returns!

    Think of the stimulus we’d have if Congress said, just for one year, we’re taking a flat 10%. Some would pay more, some less, but the stock in aspirin, ibuprofen, and other headache medicines would plummet.

  17. Such a funny post. I sit down with the old-fashioned 1040 in print form and grind my teeth as I try to ascertain if we should take the standard deduction or itemize. Blar. I’m glad its all over for one more year.

  18. Haha! I’ve never done my own taxes, luckily, I married a woman who’s dad and sister are both accountants. I really don’t know what I’d do without them!

    • You married wisely. Unfortunately, our families have no practical skills to offer, unless you need someone to fly your Boeing 737 (my brother) or you need a lawyer to handle your multi-million dollar business merger (my husband’s brother). Between the two families, we’re lucky if we can all tie our own shoes.

  19. We don’t have 1040 here in DUblin but somehow what ever i did this year I got a 500 Euro refund in taxes … yeah me and hello new shoes

  20. After a mistake in our seemingly idiot proof turbo tax return last year (also something related to the purchase price/cost basis thing) we finally hired an accountant this year. After signing the forms and dropping in the mail all I could think of is, why are we so stupid that it took us 17 years to figure this out!

  21. Man, why do the good ones always end up in prison?

    We tried to use a free on-line program put out by one of the big tax firms a few years ago, and it refused to let us claim our third kid as a deduction. So we did our taxes three times that year. Bourbon anyone?

  22. it’s not difficult. i use average1040.com. cost about $9 to file online, refund directly sent to your bank account. they will also file certain state returns at no extra charge. piece of cake.

  23. Hahaha, this is fantastic. Glad you got it figured out, TurboTax does make it a lot easier. And I think if there’s unfamiliar terms it might define them for you, but I’m not entirely sure on that one. Congrats on Freshly Pressed!

  24. Ah yes, tax season. Glad that people smarter than me can’t figure it out, either!

    Also, couldn’t help but notice you write for the Indiana Gazette. I go to IUP (I’m actually writing this from a computer in Sutton…) so it was weird to see that connection on WordPress! 🙂

    • WOOT! Shout out to IUP! Although you might hate me because I am just a lousy townie in Indiana – I grew up there but went off to college in OH, in an even smaller town if you can believe it!

      • I’m from a small town, too, so I get the “townie” mentality. I’m having a great time at IUP, though. 🙂

        • Stay out of those Frat houses – I remember being at one of those IUP frat parties and the house was so grungy — my big hair got stuck in fly paper they had hanging from the ceiling in their party room!!

  25. Haha, this was really funny. Like REALLY funny. Mainly because it’s a startling similar situation as my wife and I find ourselves in year in and year out. Never got involved with a shady accountant however. That one is all you! Congrats on FP by the way. Really good piece.

  26. Oh wow, this sounds familiar. But I have a secret weapon. She is also my hero. Her name is Star, and just as her name implies, she shines endless light along my personal tax pilgrimage path. She is amazing — and somehow, even as a full-time freelance writer, I am getting a (small) refund.

    I do SO love my Star…

    And I wish you luck on your journey — though it sounds like you accomplished it without a secret weapon!

    🙂

  27. Great post, and congratulations on your “fresh-pressed” accomplishment! That isn’t likely to happen for me, as I post video guitar licks/solos and songs with tablature. Once again, congrats!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Social

Follow The Blog

Join 5,180 other subscribers

Upcoming Events!

The Author

The Book!

Featured Posts

Search